Skip to main content

"Half The Dance"


Sherman Alexie wrote a short story with a very long title: “Because My Father Always Said He Was the Only Indian Who Saw Jimi Hendrix Play the Star-Spangled Banner at Woodstock.” The story mentions four musicians (Jimi Hendrix, Elvis Presley, Hank Williams and Robert Johnson), a specific performance of the American anthem and a country song.
Reading the title, we understand that Jimi Hendrix is the central musical figure in the story. Do the characters compare him to other musical icons? Yes, an anecdote involving Hank Williams leads a perplexed narrator to tell to his father:  
“Hank Williams and Jimi Hendrix don’t have much in common[.]”
For the narrator’s father, what the two musicians have in common is their intimate knowledge of heartaches.
The father deplores his son’s ignorance and then shifts to the subject of music. This leads the father to share his personal take on instrumentation. The drums are the culprits, largely responsible for the younger generation’s insensitivity. He pleads for more piano, more guitar, more saxophone.
What technical details does the narrator mention? Reverberation is meaningful. The anthem’s first bend is ritualistically synchronized with the father’s entrance.
What relation do the characters have with the guitar? Both father and son are aware of its difficulty. The mother gives an honest account of what it was like to be wooed by her guitar-learning husband. As for the young narrator, he knows he would like to play the instrument, but he envisions it as a private affair between his senses and his imagination.   
Now let’s go back to the performance mentioned in the title. What extra-musical sounds does the narrator associate with Jimi Hendrix? They range from motorcycles (hallucinatory and real) to the father’s drunken humming and weeping.
There is also the question of context and medium. Played on the house stereo, the tape eventually gets worn out. Later on, the characters hear the revisited anthem during a dangerous car ride as a radio DJ plays the request. Fragments of the performance are heard in memories and in dreams.
How do the characters relate to the anthem and its reinterpretation? According to the narrator, his father “was the perfect hippie.” According to the father, “Indians are pretty much born soldiers anyway.” Covering the psychedelic and martial aspects of the interpretation, these statements reinforce the characters’ connection to the Woodstock performance.
We mentioned Hank Williams earlier. Did the same process of identification apply to the narrator’s parents when they heard the country waltz ‘I’m So Lonesome I Could Cry?” As the father recounts his first dance with his wife, he tells his son: “We were in this cowboy bar. We were the only cowboys there despite the fact that we’re Indians.” The answer is yes. Identification is quick, simple, natural and ironic to the extreme.
Jimi’s power is real and enduring. He brings war-torn skies to your home. He is a “snowplow” in a snowstorm. He breaks up a marriage from his grave. And his presence is such that it can temporarily cure a man’s solitude. Or perhaps not.
As the narrator reflects on his father’s reactions to music, he remarks: “Music had powerful medicine.” What other examples of music’s special properties do we find in the text? Traditional songs have a healing power. Traditional dance can be half love dedication half personal preservation.
Later, the narrator finds a special kind of knowledge in Robert Johnson’s blues. This knowledge transcends time and culture, as he is able to connect his experience to the past experiences of the bluesman.
The narrator is anxious to connect his dreams with reality. After having dreamt about it, he verifies the weather conditions of the festival in whatever films he can find. Later, in a reverse move, he makes a conscious decision to let a dream linger on. Tensions between dreams and actual experience are at the heart of the story. With the help of music, the text becomes an interface between different levels of consciousness.
Click here to listen to a Jimi and Hank mash-up.
Alexie, Sherman. “Because My Father Always Said He Was the Only Indian Who Saw Jimi Hendrix Play the Star-Spangled Banner at Woodstock.” The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, Grove Press, 2013, pp. 24-36
 



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"Coming Through Slaughter", by Michael Ondaatje (2)

I have written before about Michael Ondaatje’s novel Coming Through Slaughter (here’s the link to the English version ). A few recent searches led me to an article by Emily Petermann and the albums of Dave Lisik and Jerry Granelli. Back in 2010, Emily Petermann published an article entitled “Unheard Jazz: Music and History in Michael Ondaatje’s Coming Through Slaughter ” . Thanks to this article, I have learned the meaning of the term “ekphrasis” as it applies to the description of music in literature.   Back in 2009, Dave Lisik released a whole album based on the Ondaatje novel: Coming Through Slaughter, The Bolden Legend . Each track title is a reference to a scene from the book. If you listen to the opening track, you too will marvel at the beauty of the low end of the trombone’s range. Hear how effectively the Bb signals a repeat of the theme’s first section, as though the whole ensemble was breathing through that one tone. And what about the drummer’s cross stick work a

Hésitant, Rusé, Nerveux, Doux

Philip Roth a écrit un court roman au titre en forme d’adieux : Goodbye, Columbus . Neil Klugman, le narrateur, entame une relation amoureuse, avec Brenda Patimkin. Les Patimkin sont plus riches que la famille de Neil. Il vit avec sa tante à Newark, tandis que les Patimkin vivent à Short Hills.     L’histoire mentionne Kostelanetz et Mantovani. Des titres de chanson tels que “Night and Day,” “I Get a Kick out of You,” “Get Me to the Church on Time” ainsi que le titre de la comédie musicale My Fair Lady apparaissent dans le texte. Ce n’est que dans la seconde moitié du roman que la musique gagne du terrain. Cependant le plus merveilleux des passages sur l’expression musicale se trouve dans la première moitié du texte. Et il ne concerne pas de chanson existante. Et il ne se rapporte pas à un genre musical précis. Neil et Brenda, deux jeunes amants, apprennent à exprimer leurs sentiments l’un pour l’autre dans un échange de vers improvisés qui est à la fois timide et en

"Grandiose, in a corrupted romantic style"

Next up in our cast for Ian McEwan's revisiting of Hamlet is Claude, the hero’s uncle.   He conspires to kill his brother, John, with the help of his lover (and sister-in-law), Trudy. She is pregnant with our hero-narrator, whose hatred of Claude has some roots in the man's musical ignorance. The patronym brings about the first mention of a European composer. Whenever he introduces himself, the plotting uncle says “Claude, as in Debussy,” so as to help with the pronunciation of his name. This does not fail to disgust our narrator. (Chapter One, p. 5). For the man seems to revel in his ignorance. Claude conjures up the French composer's name as a mere icebreaker, without any interest for the composer’s works.  Our fetus-narrator sets us right immediately: “This is Claude as in property developer who composes nothing, invents nothing.” At the beginning of Chapter Three, the narrator tries to understand who his uncle really is. The description addresses the musical featu